Advantages and disadvantages of player naturalization law: Implications for football development and nationalism
Keywords:
Naturalization law, Football development, Citizenship policy, National identityAbstract
The naturalization program for football players has been a recurring issue in debates on the development of the Indonesian national team since the early 2010s. In recent years, the phenomenon has become increasingly common as part of broader efforts to enhance national team performance. Based on Law Number 12 of 2006 on Citizenship, foreigners who have provided services to Indonesia or whose presence is deemed to serve the national interest may be granted Indonesian citizenship. This study examines the implications of naturalization through a comprehensive analysis of its legal framework and its impact on multiple aspects, including the quality and competitiveness of the national team, the regeneration and opportunities for local players, and the cultivation of national identity and values. While naturalization offers potential benefits in raising the international profile and achievements of Indonesian football, it also poses challenges to domestic player development and may influence perceptions of national identity. Therefore, the practice of naturalization must be carefully balanced with policies that strengthen grassroots football, nurture local talent, and uphold the values of nationalism in sports.
References
[1] NA Maaruf, R. Singh, and I. Triadi, “Implementation of National Defense Values in the Football Player Naturalization Policy Seen from the Perspective of Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 12 of 2006 Concerning Citizenship,” Civilia J. Kaji. Huk. Dan Pendidik. Kewarganegaraan , vol. 2, no. 5, pp. 74–84, 2023.
[2] W. Wijanarko, Ramidy, and R. Tanamas, "Naturalization Rights, Achievements Of The Indonesian National Team Soared." 2024.
[3] IN Raditya, “True Nationalism of Naturalized Players.” 2016.
[4] KP and OR Indonesia, “Minister of Youth and Sports Dito Emphasizes that Naturalized Athletes Must Have Indonesian Blood and Filters and Controls Will Be Strengthened.” 2024.
[5] T. Fajriyah, “Minister of Youth and Sports Says Naturalized Players' Nationalism is Weak.” 2021.
[6] T. Tvonenews.com, “Naturalization of the Indonesian National Team.” 2024.
[7] AG Mahardika, “Legal Politics of the Citizenship Law as Optimization of the State's Role in Football in Indonesia,” J. Huk. Respublica Univ. Lancang Kuning , no. 9, pp. 29–44, 2009.
[8] GK Annas and NM Hazzar, "Analysis of Equal Citizenship Rights for Naturalized Football Players in Indonesia," J. Wicarana , vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 127–143, 2024.
[9] MA Syahrin, “Naturalization in Citizenship Law :,” J. Thengkyang , vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 36–53, 2019.
[10] R. Phispal, "Lex et Societatis , Vol. I/No. 5/September/2013," Lex Soc. , vol. I, no. 5, p. 41, 2013.
[11] FA Firdaus, A. Diamantina, and A. Soemarmi, “Rights and Obligations of Indonesian Citizens Whose Citizenship is Obtained Through Naturalization,” Diponegoro Law J. , vol. 11, no. 2, p. 5, 2022.
[12] AZ Hakim, “Protection of Citizenship Rights Based on the Principle of Equality in Terms of Naturalization of Indonesian Football Players Based on Law No. 12 of 2006 Concerning Citizenship,” 2020.
[13] P. Mindus, “The Contemporary Debate on Citizenship,” Revus , no. 9, pp. 29–44, 2009.
[14] S. Abdukllah, “plus -mines of naturalized players, good as a whip,” January 7 , 2017. .
[15] J. Duerden, “Indonesia's Foreign-Born Players: Improvement at a Cost?” 2024.
[16] Y. Revela, “plus mines of naturalized players in Indonesia,” January 18 , 2019. .
[17] Sartana, “Naturalization and the Shift in Indonesian Nationalism.” 2024.
[18] AD Sembada and D. Prasetyo, “Actualization of Pancasila in Indonesian Football,” Civ. Education-Research-Educator Service. Pancasila and Citizenship , vol. 8, no. 2, 2020.
Downloads
Published
Conference Proceedings Volume
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 A Amelia, D M Zahroh , I Zaki (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.